I recorded some 43 moths on our trip to Greece this year, and perhaps saw a few more micros of which I didn’t get photos. I’ve tabulated the full list as it stands in a separate post entitled Moths Matter in Macedonia.
As well chasing the obvious on our Greenwings butterflying and birding trip to Greece, there was also time for a few moths. Some during the day, some that overnighted in the stairwell of our little hotel, and some from fellow amateur Lepidopterist, Martine’s field trips around the village of Chrisochorafa. Thanks to Martine and Michael for IDs on the local species and for Mrs Sciencebase’s eagle eyes in spotting much of the wildlife.
Spotted my one and only clearwing moth of the trip, Pyropteron minianiformis, on our first day trekking through the disused Vironia Quarry. This was also where we saw our first Little Tiger Blue, Ilex Hairstreak, Clouded Yellow, and Nettle-tree butterflies, Masked Shrike, Levant Sparrowhawk and overhead Ravens too.
We also saw our first tortoise of the trip. We had seen our first Bee-eaters, White Stork, and Honey Buzzard en route, and heard our first frogs. There will be more about the birds and other wildlife in a subsequent post, once I have processed those photos.
The yellow and black micro moth with large, feathery antennae is a male Euplocamus ophisa (Tineidae). Spotted several of these in the stream-side woodland where the Glider butterflies were seen. No ID for the arachnid.
Mrs Sciencebase spotted the first Speckled Yellow (Pseudopanthera macularia, Geometridae) of the trip, at the Lailias Ski Centre, I think it was.
I spotted this large moth, Catocala nymphaea (Erebidae), which was roosting on a derelict building near a barely used dirt track we butterflied. It is related to Red Underwing, Crimson Underwing, Clifden Nonpareil, but, while it has orange on its hindwings, it is not an orange underwing.
The Geometrician, Grammodes stolida (Erebidae). Potted by Martine on her late-night field trip not far from Chrisochorafa.
Knot-grass (Acronicta rumicis, Noctuidae) larva feeding on spurge, I believe, Vironia Quarry
The filled band on this Riband Wave, Idaea aversata (Geometridae), is rather more pink than I have seen before.
We were watching lots of butterflies and the nectaring Hummingbird Hawk-moths on a purple patch of vetch at the side of the road up towards the Lailias Ski Centre when a couple of Broad-bordered Bee Hawk-moth, (Hemaris fuciformis, Sphingidae) put in a timely appearance.
Michael spotted a couple of Spurge Hawk-moth (Hyles euphorbiae, Sphingidae) larvae feeding on some roadside spurge, like they do.
Early-morning phone snap of a long-legged moth which was roosting at dawn at our accommodation. Euclasta splendidalis (Crambidae) is restricted to SE Europe onwards to Turkey and the Middle East. The food plant is a vine called Periploca graeca (Asclepiadaceae – Milkweed family).
There were lots of Nine-spotted Moth around on our wanderings. They are also known as the Yellow-belted Burnet (Amata phegea, Erebidae) or in Michael’s parlance, the “lazy moth” on account of their general indolence.
Wood Tiger (Parasemia plantaginis, Erebidae) spotted and potted by Martine before being released back on site for a photo or two.
The Passenger (Dysgonia algira, Noctuidae) was fluttering around the hotel stairwell with several micros when we returned from our evening meal with the Little Owls.
Black-veined Moth (Siona lineata, Geometridae), not to be confused with the Black-veined White butterfly, which we also saw.
The Handmaid
The Macedonia of my blog headline refers to the ancient Greek region which coincides with the area of modern, northern Greece where we were staying and exploring. North Macedonia was west of us, just over the border. At one point, we were within a few metres of the North Macedonian border patrol as we headed for a known site – the woodland and scrub around the Doiran Memorial – seeking, unsuccessfully as it turned out, the Tessellated Skipper butterfly.
Mrs Sciencebase and I spent a week in the beautiful wilds of northern Greece not far from the Bulgarian and North Macedonian borders in early June. At first glance, it was a holiday, but it was more realistically a fascinating international biology field trip with lots of butterflies, moths, birds, and plants to photograph and record. The list of butterflies we saw and recorded can be found below.
We had 6:30am starts most days except the 5am on Lake Kerkini boat-trip day, expertly piloted by Niko. It was certainly not the usual lounging-by-the-pool-all-day type holiday with lingering lie-ins et cetera. There was, however, all those butterflies and birds. Delicious Greek food and quaffable Greek beer every evening certainly felt holiday-like!
We were staying in a small town called Chrisochorafa, which isn’t far from the beautiful Lake Kerkini with its hundreds of pelicans (Dalmation and Great White), tens of thousands of Great Cormorant, numerous Spoonbill, various heron and egret species, and on and on!
Our expert eco-guide, Michael, kindly drove us all over the region. We swung way west to the border with North Macedonia, but also east and north almost to Bulgaria too. Michael, is a diptera and lepidoptera expert and did a bit of independent flycatching in between identifying butterflies and birds for his research. He hopes to identify the groups that may well have been lost to regions ravaged by forest fires in northeastern Greece in recent years.
We also had one other travelling companion, Martine – a modestly expert amateur lepidopterist who was a great help to us in spotting and identifying the novel species of Lepidoptera. We hiked several km most days even when it was sometimes 38 degrees Celsius in the shade.
Somehow, I managed to take more than 11000 photos. Too much of the time I had my camera in rapid-burst mode. I’ve plucked more than 500 from the SD cards. I will pull out and process what I think are the best to share here on the Sciencebase blog and on my social media. I may be some time. You Have Been Warned.
I now have photographs of dozens of species of butterfly that I’d not seen before, and we saw well over 73 species in total. Lots of birds and more than 40 moth species, more than a couple of dozen of which aren’t present in the UK and I’d not seen before. 90+ birds seen and/or heard.
I didn’t do a lot of handheld focus stacking, but I did try with the above Balkan Copper photo. It was on the ski slope at Lailias, no snow, obviously. There were quite a few other butterflies and day-flying moths here.
It’s worth noting that contractors were strimming the lovely meadow at the foot of the ski slope for some unknown reason. This will inevitably have destroyed thousands of blooms, sending the invertebrates that were thriving there into oblivion. There was presumably a good reason for the strimming, but it put paid to our butterflying on that patch.
Overall, we had a fabulous trip although some of our target species were entirely absent from even the most likely sites. Tessellated Skipper, for instance. Indeed, its larval food plant was absent from the site too. Temperatures were too high for June in this region for the whole week. This may well have contributed to the much lower than anticipated numbers and diversity of Lepidoptera, although we still saw plenty.
Here is the complete list of butterfly species of which I have now published photographs on Sciencebase. There were several others that we saw that I didn’t get photos of or that didn’t warrant sharing – Essex Skipper, Small Skipper, Dark Green Fritillary etc. I think the total count for the trip for me and Mrs Sciencebase was 73+ butterfly species.
Blue, Amanda’s (Polyommatus amandus)
Blue, Eastern Baton (Pseudophilotes vicrama)
Blue, European Common (Polyommatus icarus)
Blue, Green-underside (Glaucopsyche alexis)
Blue, Iolas (Iolana iolas)
Blue, Lang’s Short-tailed (Leptotes pirithous)
Blue, Large (Phengaris arion)
Blue, Little Tiger (Tarucus balkanicus)
Blue, Mazarine (Cyaniris semiargus,)
Blue, Small (Cupido minimus)
Brown Argus (Aricia agestis)
Brown, Large Wall (Lasiommata maera)
Brown, Lattice (Kirinia roxelana)
Brown, Meadow (Maniola jurtina)
Brown, Northern Wall (Lasiommata petropolitana)
Brown, Wall (Lasiommata megera)
Cardinal (Argynnis Pandora)
Clouded Apollo (Parnassius mnemosyne)
Clouded Yellow (Colias croceus)
Common Yellow Swallowtail (Papilio machaon)
Copper, Balkan (Lycaena candens)
Copper, Lesser Fiery (Lycaena thersamon)
Copper, Purple-shot (Lycaena alciphron)
Copper, Sooty (Lycaena tityrus)
Eastern Festoon (Allancastria cerisyi)
Fritillary, Heath (Melitaea athalia)
Fritillary, Knapweed (Melitaea phoebe)
Fritillary, Lesser Marbled (Brenthis ino)
Fritillary, Lesser Spotted (Melitaea trivia)
Fritillary, Marbled (Brenthis daphne)
Fritillary, Niobe (Fabriciana niobe)
Fritillary, Pearl-bordered (Boloria euphrosyne)
Fritillary, Queen of Spain (Issoria lathonia)
Fritillary, Silver-washed (Argynnis paphia)
Fritillary, Spotted (Melitaea didyma)
Grayling, Eastern Rock (Hipparchia syriaca)
Grayling, Great Banded (Brintesia circe)
Hairstreak, Blue-spot (Satyrium spini)
Hairstreak, Green (Callophrys rubi)
Hairstreak, Ilex (Satyrium ilicis)
Hairstreak, Sloe (Satyrium acacia)
Hairstreak, White-letter (Satyrium w-album)
Heath, Pearly (Coenonympha arcania)
Heath, Small (Coenonympha pamphilus)
Hermit (Chazara briseis)
Nettle-tree Butterfly (Libythea celtis)
Painted Lady (Vanessa cardui)
Scarce Swallowtail (Iphiclides podalirius)
Skipper, Dingy (Erynnis tages)
Skipper, Grizzled (Pyrgus malvae)
Skipper, Large (Ochlodes sylvanus)
Skipper, Mallow (Carcharodus alceae)
Skipper, Yellow-banded (Pyrgus sidae)
Southern White Admiral (Limenitis reducta)
Tortoiseshell, Large (Nymphalis polychloros)
Tortoiseshell, Small (Aglais urticae)
White, Balkan Marbled (Melanargia larissa)
White, Black-veined (Aporia crataegi)
White, Eastern Bath (Pontia edusa)
White, Marbled (Melanargia galathea)
White, Small (Pieris rapae)
White, Wood (Leptidea sinapis)
Woodland Ringlet (Erebia medusa)
Technical footnotes
I took rather a lot of photos on this week-long trip (well over 10,000) and then spent the weekend pulling out what I think are the best. I’ve got about 500 that I need to work through and do a second-line purge.
I will process the select few from the camera RAW files using DxO PureRaw4, which I’ve mentioned previously. This software carries out corrections to the photos you take based on the known distortions associated with your camera and lens combination. Its main purpose however is to remove noise from an image without removing detail. It does this very well, improving any photo you feed it to the tune of 3 or so full stops of ISO. This can make all the difference with photos shot in the limited light of a woodland or at twilight.
Some of the photos need a different kind of processing and I’ll use Topaz Sharpen for the ones that could do with a bit more tightening up to remove motion blur, for instance.
This year’s crop of the rather rare Black Hairstreak began emerging at Brampton Wood on 29th May. I didn’t get a chance to visit the site until the 5th June. Intermittent sun meant they butterflies would appear, flit about a bit, and then disappear when the clouds moved across the sun again. There are lots on this site and several other woodlands that dot the landscape between Huntingdonshire and Oxfordshire.
The species is on the wing for a couple of weeks at this time of year mating in and around the old Blackthorn bushes in these woodlands, with that plant being the larval food plant. Unfortunately, unlike some other species, the Black Hairstreak is not a colonialist and it is common that the adults will fly no more than a few metres from the site where they first emerged from their pupae.
A couple of years ago, the transect count for the site was 2000 or so Black Hairstreak. Given the expanse of this woodland, it’s possible that that there were tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of adult butterflies on the site that summer. It’s nationally rare, and like I say, there are very few places where you will see them, but if you know the right spot…
Incidentally, had a chat with Alice from GreenWings and Steve from Butterfly Conservation. He pointed out a Lackey Moth larva on a tree as we walked from the first BH site to the second site.
I had reason to be in the vicinity of Trumpington Meadows today and although the wildflowers are coming on, very little is in bloom relative to what we see there at the summer peak. There was some Red Campion, Bladder Campion, some Common Vetch, Oxeye Daisy, Red Clover, a tiny bit of early Field Scabious and a few other bits and bobs. I didn’t have high hopes for seeing an early Marbled White or the Small Blues which enjoy the Kidney Vetch there. And, indeed, there were no Marbled Whites on show, but there was a mating pair of Small Blue!
There were numerous Brimstone, Orange Tip, and Peacock, and we had a solitary sighting of Red Admiral. There was a lone Holly Blue at the car park and just one Common Blue (first of the year for me) on the area close to Byron’s Pool. A single Silver Y moth put in an appearance too and a single Green-veined White.
It was over the M11 foot and cycle bridge where there are often more Small Blue in the flying season that we saw half a dozen or so Small Heath (first ones of the year) and then caught sight of the in copulo pair of Small Blue. Dancing among them numerous Grass Rivulet moths, which I’d first seen here in 2022.
It’s been an odd year so far for us moth-ers. There was an odd burst of numbers and diversity back in mid-March but that was followed by some very lean lighting-ups in April when it was generally cold and wet forever. It was only on the 8th May that there was a sudden up-tick. We had warmer evenings and on the night of 12th May, I recorded 36 moths of 25 species. 14 of those were new for the year (NFY) and one of them, Grey Pine Carpet, was new for my garden (NFM).
Next session, wasn’t quite as rich, but there were still seven species NFY, including a couple of Pale Tussock, a Maiden’s Blush, Pebble Hook-tip, The Spectacle, and a White Point. Moth names are just as diverse as the moths themselves.
So, as of 13th May, that’s 84 lighting-up sessions mainly with a 15W Wemlite UV fluorescent tube on a Robinson trap. The next few weeks will hopefully see diversity and numbers rising still further.
I’ve written about the industrial evolution of the Peppered Moth on numerous occasions. It’s held up as an example of evolution in action. Here’s the non-melanic, “clean air” form that turned up on the night of 14th May.
The Silver Y is a migrant species turning up in their thousands some years if conditions are right. It is found all over the UK, but seen most commonly, and obviously, at coastal watch points. Its name comes from the silvery Y shaped marking on its wings. The scientific name is Autographa gamma, which suggests that the marking might also be the third letter of the Greek alphabet, gamma. Often to be seen nectaring on wildflowers and garden flowers during the day, at dusk, and at night.
I usually see well over 300 species in the garden over the course of the year and a few dozen of those are NFM (see definition above). I’ve been mothing since late July 2018 and at last count garden “list” stands at well over 500 species.
An update at this point in the year when it seems to be turning seemed timely.
Footnote
All moths are released unharmed back into the wild well away from the trap after logging and any photography I do. All my records are sent annually to the County Moth Recorder for logging on the county and national databases so adding to our understanding of distribution of different species at the local and national level. Such scientific information can help inform those involved in conservation, agriculture, development, and other activities on which the presence or absence of moths has an impact.
This tiny little creature is the Diamond-back Moth, Plutella xylostella. It’s just a few millimetres long, so snapped with a 30mm extension tube on a Tamron 90mm 1:1 macro lens on a Canon R7 to get as close as possible.
The image was focus stacked, in camera, to improve depth of field and then denoised and sharpened a little with Topaz Sharpen AI. There is a new Topaz product out now that replaces the original Sharpen and Denoise modules. If they send me it to review, I’ll give you the low-down, but it looks good from the demos I’ve seen. Final tweaks to levels and contrast, cropping, and logo done in PaintShopPro, which is a cheap and cheerful substitute for the more well known PhotoShop.
The species is a high-flying, long-distance migrant, that probably originated in Europe, specifically the Mediterranean, or possibly South Africa, it’s present the world over now.
It’s sometimes known as the Cabbage Moth, although not to be confused with another species with that vernacular name. It does eat brassicas. Farmers who plant wintercress on the margins of the brassica fields will generally find that the female of the species will be more attracted to the wintercress than the cabbages etc.
Unfortunately for the moth, while watercress is attractive it is inedible for the larvae that hatch and they die. This biological answer avoids pesticide use and given that the species has evolved resistance to pesticides seems like a good way forward for protecting crops.
Also, new for the year (NFY) in our garden last couple of trapping nights: Swallow Prominent, Ruby Tiger, Waved Umber, Common Pug, Dagger (Grey or Dark no way to know without genital dissection).
I’ve talked about warblers before. Basically, the warblers are a non-scientific grouping of similar birds. In the UK, we often see and hear a variety of warblers, mostly summer visitors, among them Blackcap, Cetti’s Warbler, Chiffchaff, Garden Warbler (Sylvia borin), Grasshopper Warbler, Great Reed Warbler (occasionally), Lesser Whitethroat, Reed Warbler, Sedge Warbler, Whitethroat, and Willow Warbler.
I headed to RSPB Fen Drayton Lakes nature reserve on a promise of Arctic Terns as a big influx had been reported on Tuesday, some 36, arriving in two waves, 29 and then 7, from Grafham Water. This is a huge number for one inland patch, especially in East Anglia.
More often, we’d have Common Terns and only a sporadic appearance of single figures Arctic. I had alerted the local birding community to a Sandwich Tern on 17th April 2024. A relative rarity that unusually stuck around for several days at the reserve. We also get Black Tern on these lakes.
Anyway, I saw just a few of the Arctic Terns on the water. However, a nice patch facing out over Ferry Lagoon fringed with some very noisy trees and bushes had Garden Warbler and Sedge Warbler calling noisily alongside Chiffchaff, Lesser Whitethroat, and Willow Warbler. There were several of each species. There were also two or three Cuckoo calling from far off trees. That aside, I got a shot of one of the Garden Warblers. I thought it was my first attempt at photographing this bird, but I discovered that I had photos of it in the warbler post from 2022.
At least 43 birds on sight or sound this morning:
Arctic Tern
Blackbird
Black-headed Gull
Blue Tit
Bittern
Carrion Crow
Chaffinch
Chiffchaff
Common Tern
Coot
Cormorant
Cuckoo
Dunnock
Garden Warbler
Goldcrest
Goldfinch
Great Crested Grebe
Great Tit
Greenfinch
Green Woodpecker
Greylag Goose
House Martin
Kestrel
Lesser Whitethroat
Long-tailed Tit
Magpie
Mallard
Marsh Harrier
Moorhen
Mute Swan
Pheasant
Robin
Rook
Sand Martin
Sedge Warbler
Song Thrush
Starling
Swallow
Swift
Whitethroat
Willow Warbler
Wood Pigeon
Wren
Footnote: We do see Grasshopper Warblers (Groppers) locally, but I didn’t today. Dartford Warbler was seen a couple of summers ago, but a fairly rare sight. I’ve seen the rather rare Wood Warbler, but not in the UK, it was up the hill in Split, Croatia, back in 2017 before we drank all that dark ale on the way down and had catfish and chips for tea.
More about the British warblers on the BBC Countryfile site here.
Mrs Sciencebase and I opted to follow the footpath from the RSPB Ouse Fen (Earith) car park to what we refer to as the “Clouded Yellow Field”, which is the patch where we saw that butterfly in numbers in 2022 and that leads on to Brownshill Staunch where I spotted the previously mentioned Sandwich Tern.
It’s a nice stretch to stretch one’s legs. Lots of Marsh Harrier activity over the reed beds, Chinese Water Deer and Roe Deer to see. Calls from Sedge Warbler, White Throat, Chiff Chaff (all warblers). We could hear some Bearded Reedling calling and Bittern booming and saw two different pairs of that latter species flying over the reedbeds. Also plenty of Reed Bunting around resplendant in their breeding plumage.
If this bird were named in the same way as one of its close relatives, Emberiza citrinella, it would be called a Reedhammer (as in Yellowhammer, where “hammer/ammer” is old German for “bunting”. Of course, in modern German the Yellowhammer is the “Goldammer”, while the Reed Bunt is “Rohrammer”, Rohr meaning pipe and presumably alluding to the pipe-like reeds.
In my photo you can see an example of why it’s important to get a catchlight in the eye of a bird or other animal. Without that tiny glint of reflected light, the eye would have little character and with a bird like this would be lost against the black of its facial plumage.
I used DxO PureRaw4 to do automatic lens and camera corrections and to denoise the RAW file from the Canon R7 (lens was Sigma 150-600mm at full extent). I then ran the DNG output from PureRaw4 through Topaz Sharpen AI v 4.1.0 to tighten up those feathers a little and then PaintShopPro Ultimate 2022 to tweak levels ever so slightly and to crop and add my logo. Camera settings: f/6.3, t 1/4000s, ISO 800.
The image below is an unedited JPG grab from the original camera RAW file
Yesterday, I spotted a Sandwich Tern, Thalasseus sandvicensis, colloquially known as a Sarnie, patrolling the open river lock at Brownshill Staunch on the Great River Ouse. It flew back and forth over a stretch of about 200 metres for 20 minutes or so before heading off downstream.
The river cuts through the RSPB Ouse Fen nature reserve (I’d walked in from the Over end rather than Needingworth). The lock is currently open to allow flood water to run to the sea, although it’s not flowing as violently as it was about a month ago.
Anyway, I’ve seen several Common Terns fishing on this reserve and a Black Tern fly through one pre-covid summer. But, a Sandwich seemed unusual so I posted my spot to the local patch’s birding social media group when I first saw it. There was a flurry of interest and one member, Richard Thomas, keen to see the bird, headed to the Staunch. Unfortunately, for him the bird had moved on by the time he arrived, and I hadn’t checked back in on the group after my initial update to let them know. He dipped out. My bad.
I later spoke to Richard about the presence of the Sandwich Tern. I had assumed it wasn’t a so-called mega rarity, but still its presence was rather unusual. He told me he thinks they’re almost annual in this area despite their being so obviously coastal feeders and breeders.
“Sandwich Terns are just about annual locally – I’ve seen them on six occasions in 20 years and missed them more times than that,” Richard told me. “They are an absolute pain in the neck because they rarely stay more than a few minutes. I’ve been lucky on four occasions with “fly throughs” (including a flock of seven at the Brownshill Staunch).” He added that they’re annual at Grafham Water reservoir, which isn’t far from here either and a nice birding spot, but again, he says, they were almost invariably fly throughs.
There was a subsequent flurry of activity in the social media group, my having alerted the birders to the presence of the species, and it was quickly tracked down to yet another patch of old gravel pits turned nature reserve, RSPB Fen Drayton. Several birders were excited to know it was there and surprised that it had roosted rather than flying through.
The River Great Ouse empties into The Wash on the north Norfolk coast. It’s worth noting that Brownshill Staunch, which lies on the Greenwich Meridian, is the last stretch of the river that still feels the effects of the tide. In recent weeks, my fellow togger friend Andy Hoy saw a seal sunning itself on the riverbank at this point. It had presumably swum upstream from the coast. Seals are not uncommon on the river, although they’re usually seen further downstream. In the summer of 2023, a female dolphin and two offspring were seen on this stretch of river too.
Richard has the last word in adding that one good tern deserves another, he suggests that Caspian Tern or Roseate Tern would be firsts for the patch should they turn up…
Latest intel on the Sarnie is that it’s feeding on the river near Ferry Lagoon at RSPB Fen Drayton 18h00 on the 18th April. On the 17th it roosted on the islands in the Lagoon. The bird was still being seen on 20th April. Interesting that quite rare for this species to stay in Cambridgeshire this long. Some birders said not known it before, others pointed out that one may have over-wintered at Grafham Water in 1987.
If you have even a passing interest in the natural world, you will have most likely heard the phrase “invasive species”. By definition, a deliberate or accidental release of a species to an area beyond its natural environment where it then multiplies and causes damage to that environment and the native wildlife that relies on it. I discussed the UK issue of invasive species briefly last year and in the context of Muntjac and Black Hairstreak butterfly too.
Ecologist and conservationist Hugh Warwick tackles the issue in much more depth in his latest book – Cull of the Wild. Warwick is, as most of us are, not keen on killing in the name of and recognises that the arguments and issues regarding the culling of invasive species where they threaten the very existence of native species and ecosystems are still very complicated.
In Cull of the Wild, he discusses how different approaches to control have been tried worldwide. The grey versus red squirrels, the cane toads in Australia, rats, even Pablo Escobar’s hippos and the Burmese python trade.
Warwick, a former vegan and now a self-confessed meat-eschewing vague-an, points out that millions of animals are killed, or culled, every year in the name of conservation, invasive species, feral populations, domestic animals. Sadly, much of this killing is cruel and essentially unregulated. To quote from Warwick’s introduction:
“We deserve an honest conversation about conservation. To do that we need to establish one very important point. Conservation, wildlife management, and the ecology that underpins them both, is really complicated. Add to this one more variable: people with differing perspectives. Now, it becomes close to impossible to solve the very real problems with which we are confronted. Complicated problems rarely have simple solutions…”
There are, we learn, no absolutes. Each invasive case has nuance where humans have destroyed habitat and the native species that once filled a niche are long gone, an incomer might fill that space and become prevalent. It might be that the new species brings benefits to that environment, perhaps reducing plant overgrowth and opening up biodiversity that resurrects the habitat.
The beautiful Box-tree moth, Cydalima perspectalis, represents an interesting example of the kind of nuance we have to address. It arrived in the UK around 2007, presumably hitching a ride on imported Asian strains of box-tree, Buxus. Unfortunately, it has spread and thrived, ravaging decorative box hedges across southern England.
There is little that can be done to control this invasive species at this point in its history other than grubbing out its larval food plants, Buxus, and planting something else. Insectidal sprays are not the answer as they kill the native species too, pheromone traps are of limited use and while they kill some of the males there will always be another to fertilise the female’s eggs on one’s box hedge, and picking off caterpillars for, ahem, disposal, is not the most pleasant way to spend a lazy Sunday afternoon.
However, to talk of the lack of the nuance and the lack of absolutes, it’s worth noting that Blackbirds are starting to recognise the larvae of this moth as a rich food source. So, whereas the presence of the moth is essentially well-balanced in its native environment, there is hope that this might happen naturally here too.
It is unlikely that many of the problematic invasive species we must cope with will naturalise in that way, so there may well forever be a need to find ways to control them or live with them. Warwick offers much for our consideration of the nuances of invasion.